Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Dialectical Tensions
A couple weeks ago, we discussed how tensions within the classroom effects other's ability to participate and feel. It really seemed like the whole class was quite engaged in the topic. For me, I feel that I sometimes I raise my hand way too much. It blocks other's abilities to actually participate. But, when no-one says something or even tries to raise there hand when the professor asks us a question, I feel like we shouldn't just leave her hanging. That's when I raise my hand and try to make an educated guess, or a truthful response. As of recent, I have been trying to keep my hand down much more than what I did in the beginning of the semester. After reading the article, it made me realize that everyone has their own ways of learning and participating. The article stated that sometimes, students feel that they should shy away form answering questions because other's will automatically do it for them. The ones who are prominently always raising their hands, makes it harder for the ones who feel they have an answer, but don't want to share. This also effects their ability to participate in other classes, as well as in life situations. One thing that I found most interesting in the class discussion, was: who should take control of someone blurting out and making it hard for others to pay attention. The professor or the students? I felt the students should be able to tell other classmates how they feel. we're all grown adults, this isn't high school anymore. we don't have our professors holding our hands. It should be up to us to make those decisions and how we should deal with it. Granted the professor should have power over us, but we should be able to speak our mind, and be respectful to our fellow peers as well.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I completely agree. Sometimes I feel like I raise my hand way to much but I don't want to keep the professor hanging as well.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate you trying to help out the class a little bit. The article listed a bunch of different reasons why people speak and don't speak in class, so it's hard to find a single answer to make people speak. I think it helps if the teacher just asks someone to speak. We can't say no to that!
ReplyDeleteI totally get how you feel. I feel like I talk WAY too much in that class, and I too have been trying not to talk as much. I've noticed that a few others have spoken up who I have not heard much from in class, which is great!
ReplyDeleteLet me give some feedback from both perspectives. I personally learn through discussions, so I understand how it is hard to keep quiet. I also know how frustrating it is to be in a class where one student won't be quiet. However from a teacher's perspective, it is important for students to answer, and many times one answer can spark a light inside another student. As long as you are respectful and let others speak, I don't see a problem with raising your hand. Just to let you guy know... if you can't keep your ideas to yourself, this might be a sign that grad school is for you.... please talk to me if you have any interest of questions about it!
ReplyDelete